What if Utility Functions do not Exist?
This report has yet to be scanned by Contrails staff
Author(s):
Roberts, Fred S.
Corporate Author(s): RAND Corporation
Corporate Report Number: R-528-ARPA
Date of Publication: 1970-09
Pages: 35
Contract: DAHC15 67 C 0141
DoD Task:
Identifier: AD0712762
Abstract:
The document discusses alternatives to the strict decisionmaking goal of ranking all alternatives or, equivalently, obtaining a utility function. For many military problems, the best information available is the combined judgements of experts. Often, however, the preferences of decisionmakers are too inconsistent or ambiguous to permit a complete ranking of alternatives or a utility function. Optional methods for dealing with such a situation include finding a procedure through which preferences can be modified to obtain a utility function; using the utility assignment that best approximates a utility function; or modifying the demands on utility functions. The study emphasizes the third alternative, and describes it in terms of techniques from the theory of measurement, recently developed by behavioral scientists, that facilitate decisionmaking where no utility functions exist.
Provenance: Borg-Warner
Corporate Author(s): RAND Corporation
Corporate Report Number: R-528-ARPA
Date of Publication: 1970-09
Pages: 35
Contract: DAHC15 67 C 0141
DoD Task:
Identifier: AD0712762
Abstract:
The document discusses alternatives to the strict decisionmaking goal of ranking all alternatives or, equivalently, obtaining a utility function. For many military problems, the best information available is the combined judgements of experts. Often, however, the preferences of decisionmakers are too inconsistent or ambiguous to permit a complete ranking of alternatives or a utility function. Optional methods for dealing with such a situation include finding a procedure through which preferences can be modified to obtain a utility function; using the utility assignment that best approximates a utility function; or modifying the demands on utility functions. The study emphasizes the third alternative, and describes it in terms of techniques from the theory of measurement, recently developed by behavioral scientists, that facilitate decisionmaking where no utility functions exist.
Provenance: Borg-Warner